Tequila Ratings

Filed under: Tequila Ratings
Share Button

THE CRITICO TEQUILA RATING LOGOWelcome to the The Critico® Tequila Ratings Page. In this section you will find a list of all tequila ratings grouped by category.

After tequila is rated we issue our tequila ratings logo depicting the category and points attained. We also license our tequila ratings to participating partners like TequilaSpectator.com, so be sure to look for the word “THE CRITICO® OFFICIAL TEQUILA RATING CO.” in the ring surrounding the rating logo.

If you would like to recommend a product for us to include in future tequila ratings please e-mail us at info@thecritico.com, we are adding new tequilas every month and we would love to hear from you.

Products we rate:
We only rate or provide tequila ratings for 100% Blue Agave Tequila. To read the regulations established by Consejo Regulador del Tequila, A.C. (Tequila Regulatory Council) on what can be named 100% Tequila please visit http://www.crt.org.mx

Our tastings:
Tequila ratings provided on this site are performed in blind tastings by a minimum of three of our Tequila Taste Masters, of which a minimum of two must be certified as Tequilier & Catador by the Academia Mexicana del Tequila, A.C.

The TEQUILA RATINGS & POINTS:
95-100= Excellent Tequila, Very Fine Quality
90-94= Very Good Tequila, High Quality
80-89= Good Tequila, Good Quality
69-79= Average Tequila, Everyday Quality
50-68= Below Average Tequila, Low Quality
0-49= Bad Tequila, Avoid Quality

BLANCO TEQUILA
( NOT AGED, BOTTLED IN 0 – 60 DAYS)
TEQUILA NAME: TEQUILA RATING: RATED MONTH/YEAR: BOTTLE No:
Agave Dos Mil Tequila Blanco 89 PTS December 2012 LOTE No.01
Aha Toro Blanco 86 PTS March 2011 126
Amate Silver 89 PTS June 2011 L-18041109
ArteNOM Blanco – Selecccion de 1079 90 PTS August 2012 Lote No. 133
Asombroso Silver 89 PTS July 2011 5,300 | LOT No. 56
Avion Silver 91 PTS February 2011 2050 | BATCH No. OL9AST
Azunia Platinum 93 PTS July 2011 NO NUM
Bonita Platinum 85 PTS February 2013 1712 | 2012
Cabo Wabo Blanco 83 PTS January 2011 NO NUM
Campeon Blanco 89 PTS August 2011 NO NUM
Casamigos Blanco In progress August 2014 23122 LOTE 8LB001L12E 28 DIC 12
Casa Noble Crystal 89 PTS May 2011 L-18061008
Cazadores Blanco Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Chinaco Blanco Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Cocula Silver 92 PTS April 2011 NO NUM
Corazon de Agave Tequila Blanco 93 PTS March 2011 NO NUM
Corralejo Blanco 89 PTS January 2011 NO NUM
Corzo Silver 88 PTS April 2011 L1007506542 MC8 9K1-ERB
Cruz Del Sol Silver 79 PTS February 2011 30993 RA
Cuestion Blanco 83 PTS October 2011 200111 CUESTIBCOEXP-10
D Los Altos Blanco Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
DeLeon Diamante Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Don Fulano Blanco Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Don Fulano Blanco Fuerte Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Don Julio Blanco 94 PTS January 2011 153728 | L10 315 046 3U6 13:51
Don Pilar Blanco 70 PTS January 2012 LOTE-112-001-DP1210
El Gran Jubileo Blanco 83 PTS June 2011 LOTE GJT2012
El Jimador Blanco In Progress August 2014 LOTE 12271C2221
El Llano Blanco 90 PTS June 2012 No Num
Espolon Blanco 88 PTS July 2011 02/LOTE/033 29/JUL/2010
Fortaleza Blanco 93 PTS May 2011 B-L-09
Frida Kahlo Blanco 90 PTS September 2011 LBE1013
Gaviota Blanco In Progress August 2014 LOTE 1220G1013
Gran Centenario Plata Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Herradura Silver 90 PTS February 2011 09 JUL 09 | LOTE 081017075
Hotel California Blanco 90 PTS December 2011 L01511/1/3
Jose Cuervo Reserva De La Familia Platino 87 PTS April 2012 07366 04-XI-08
Jose Cuervo Tradicional Silver 84 PTS April 2012 013 11 E045 261 03:10 3
Julio Cesar Chavez Tequila Blanco 89 PTS February 2013 No Num
Kah Blanco 79 PTS May 2011 75025/1011A
Karma Silver 86 PTS March 2011 72,015 | T/B 020911/KARMA
Los Azulejos Silver 85 PTS June 2011 LOTE:CBN 018 06/08
Manana Blanco 83 PTS June 2012 TMBCO1143
Maya Blanco Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Nobleza Azul Blanco 93 PTS May 2012 NABCO1125 LALO150611
Ocho Plata 2009 Agaves De Rancho Las Pomez 92 PTS July 2011 35,525
Ocho Plata 2011 El Purtecito 88 PTS August 2012 2,937
Partida Blanco 89 PTS February 2011 PA 97
Patron Platinum Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Patron Silver Re-rating in progress Re-rating in progress N/A
Pedro Infante Blanco In Progress August 2014 LOTE PIB 002 050711
Pintoresco Blanco 91 PTS August 2011 54/2400 | 1341108
Senda Real Silver In Progress August 2014 LOTE 30313-SRS
Sin Rival Silver Re-rating in progress N/A N/A
Sparkle Donkey Tequila Silver 90 PTS February 2013 CBN 064 27/06/12
Tres Generaciones Plata Re-rating in progress N/A N/A
Trianon Blanco In Progress August 2014 014BCO40
Yeyo Silver 91 PTS January 2012 NO NUM
3 Amigos Blanco 93 PTS December 2012 3AMIGOS/SILVERORGANICO/001 06/09/2011
7 Lenguas Blanco Re-rating in progress Re-rating in progress N/A
901 Silver 79 PTS May 2011 NO NUM
JOVEN
( BLEND OF 100% AGAVE TEQUILA)
TEQUILA BRAND NAME: RATING POINTS: MONTH/YEAR RATED: BOTTLE No:
Casa Dragones 95 PTS June 2011 1610 LOTE 05 03/16/10
Casa Noble Joven Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
REPOSADO
( AGED, 2 – 11 MONTHS)
TEQUILA NAME: RATING POINTS: MONTH/YEAR RATED: BOTTLE No:
Agave Dos Mil Tequila Reposado 82 PTS December 2012 LOTE No.01
Aha Toro Reposado 91 PTS March 2011 246
Amate Reposado 92 PTS June 2011 L-19011109
Amigo bf4e Reposado 83 PTS March 2011 LOTE No.241
Artillero Reposado 77 PTS January 2011 NO NUM
Arta Reposado 89 PTS July 2011 AGA/44/10/ARTA.R.E.
ArteNOM Reposado – Selecccion de 1414 90 PTS August 2012 Lote ANREP1137
Asombroso La Rosa Reposado 86 PTS April 2012 Lote No 49 2302
Avion Reposado 91 PTS February 2011 3738 | BATCH No.009ART
Cabo Wabo Tequila Reposado 74 PTS December 2012 13/LOTE/035
Camarena Tequila Reposado 83 PTS December 2012 L8251011 08:28 LM059 R3
Campion Reposado 87 PTS August 2011 T/R 211010/TV
Carmessi 89 PTS March 2011 081106 10:02 240806 C
Casamigos Reposado In progress August 2014 22120 LOTE 8LR001L12E 28 DIC 12
Casta Pasion Reposado (Square Bottle) 89 PTS July 2011 LOTE No.28
Cazadores Reposado 86 PTS January 2011 NO NUM
Chinaco Reposado Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Cocula Reposado 90 PTS April 2011 NO NUM
Corazon De Agave Reposado Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Corralejo Reposado Triple Distilled 89 PTS January 2011 NO NUM
Corralejo Reposado 91 PTS January 2011 NO NUM
Corzo Reposado 86 PTS April 2011 L1014507022 MC7 9L1-ECRR
Cruz Del Sol Reposado 84 PTS February 2011 15836 SA
Cuestion Reposado 77 PTS October 2011 050511 CUESTREPEXP-11
D Los Altos Reposado 90 PTS May 2011 NO NUM
DeLeon Reposado Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Don Fulano Reposado Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Don Julio Reposado 91 PTS January 2011 153728 | L10 315 046 3U6 13:51
El Gran Jubileo Reposado 75 PTS June 2011 LOTE GJT2013
El Jimador Reposado In Progress August 2014 LOTE 12271C1352
El Llano Reposado 90 PTS June 2012 No Num
Espolon Reposado 88 PTS May 2011 01/LOTE/043 | 01/SEP/2010
Fortaleza Reposado Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Frida Kahlo Reposado 90 PTS September 2011 LRE8001
Gaviota Reposado In Progress August 2014 LOTE L221G1013
Gila Tequila Reposado 86 PTS August 2012 270Z12 P:TQ:1:2:1
Gran Centenario Reposado Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Hacienda de la Flor Millenium 2000 79 PTS April 2011 No.6746
Herradura Reposado 90 PTS February 2011 294/8 16:13 L14
Hornitos Tequila Reposado 60 PTS December 2012 L11214S318 T31427
Hotel California Reposado 93 PTS December 2011 L02111/285
Jose Cuervo Tradicional Reposado Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Julio Cesar Chavez Tequila Reposado 92 PTS February 2013 No Num
Kah Reposado 76 PTS May 2011 75026/1011A
Karma Reposado 90 PTS March 2011 1456
La Tilica Reposado 86 PTS June 2012 LTR 010312
Los Azulejos Reposado 83 PTS June 2011 No.T0DE 388
Maestro Dobel Reposado 90 PTS June 2011 No.18,384 | DATE:24/ENE/11
Manana Reposado 83 PTS June 2012 TMREP1144
Maya Reposado Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Milagro Tequila Reposado Reserva Barrica Selecta 80 PTS December 2012 221 | 2840 BR | 030408 8E7780411
Nobleza Azul Reposado 95 PTS May 2012 NAREP1002
Ocho Reposado 2009 Agaves De Rancho Las Pomez 90 PTS August 2012 7,844
Partida Reposado 90 PTS February 2011 PA 69
Patron Reposado 85 PTS January 2011 NO NUM
Pedro Infante Reposado In Progress August 2014 LOTE PIR 002 060711
Pueblo Viejo Reposado 87 PTS March 2011 NO NUM
Real de Penjamo Artesanal 85 PTS April 2011 RPSD-13-DIC-05
Senda Real Gold/Reposado In Progress August 2014 LOTE 33713-SRG
Sin Rival Reposado 90 PTS April 2011 2 500310
Sparkle Donkey Tequila Reposado 90 PTS February 2013 CREPN 043 27/06/12
Tevado Reposado 68 PTS May 2011 L7289J LOTETV004R
Tres Generaciones Reposado Re-rating in progress N/A N/A
Tres Mujeres Reposado 90 Points August 2011 LOTE 2 500310
Trianon Reposado In Progress August 2014 012REP40
3 Amigos Reposado In Progress August 2014 3AMIGOS/REP/003 04/12/2008
ANEJO
( AGED, MINIMUM OF 1 YEAR)
TEQUILA NAME: RATING POINTS: MONTH/YEAR RATED: BOTTLE No:
Agave Dos Mil Tequila Anejo 84 PTS December 2012 LOTE No.01
Aha Toro Anejo 90 PTS March 2011 33
Amate Anejo 92 PTS June 2011 L-02041109
ArteNOM Anejo – Selecccion de 1146 91 PTS August 2012 Lote 91ASA12
Avion Anejo 90 PTS February 2011 131 | BATCH No.002AAT
Cabo Wabo Anejo Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Campion Anejo 85 PTS August 2011 T/A 240111/TV
Casa Cofradia Anejo 35% Alc. Vol. 85 PTS August 2012 L-14061211
Castillo Maya Anejo 70 PTS January 2011 NO NUM
Cazadores Anejo 84 PTS January 2011 L1004715151 MC6 10B1-ECA
Chamucos Tequila Anejo 87 PTS February 2013 LOTE CHAOO4 20/120011
Chinaco Anejo Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Cocula Anejo 93 PTS May 2011 NO NUM
Corazon De Agave Anejo Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Corralejo Anejo 79 PTS January 2011 NO NUM
Corralejo 99,000 Horas Anejo 79 PTS February 2011 010475 | LOTE.9091037
Corzo Anejo 80 PTS April 2011 L0930918352 MC8 9K1-ECRA
Cuestion Anejo 70 PTS October 2011 050511 CUESTANEXP-11
D Los Altos Anejo Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
DeLeon Anejo 91 PTS June 2012 LOTE A01
Don Fulano Anejo Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Don Julio Anejo 92 PTS January 2011 NO NUM
Don Julio 1942 96 PTS January 2011 1st YEAR LIMITED PRODUCTION Bottle 0001701
Don Julio 1942 93 PTS August 2012 NEW 2012 LIMITED PRODUCTION
Don Julio 70th Anniversary 94 PTS January 2011 L112180150W M 06:14
Don Pilar Anejo 93 PTS September 2011 LOTE-071-11-OP-1008
El Jimador Anejo 79 January 2011 N/A
El Llano Anejo Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Fortaleza Anejo Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Frida Kahlo Anejo 94 PTS September 2011 LAE5902
Gaviota Anejo In Progress August 2014 LOTE L222G1013
Gran Centenario Anejo 89 PTS April 2012 58822
Herradura Anejo 91 PTS February 2011 03 JUL 09 MQ3 07:35 | LOTE. 080925085
Hotel California Anejo 92 PTS August 2011 L04010/197
Kah Anejo 78 PTS May 2011 NO NUM
Lapis Tequila Anejo 84 PTS February 2013 LOT 42LR2 180902 | 42LR2 2309
Los Azulejos Anejo 87 PTS June 2011 No.CANEH 0B7
Manana Anejo 92 PTS June 2012 TMANE1145
Maya Anejo Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Mexican Moonshine Anejo In Progress August 2014 75034/1302A
Nobleza Azul Anejo Coming soon N/A N/A
Ocho Anejo No yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Orgullo Pueblo Viejo 88 PTS March 2011 02275
Partida Anejo 90 PTS February 2011 PA 70
Patron Anejo 79 PTS January 2011 NO NUM
Reserva De Mexico Tequila Anejo 74 PTS February 2013 LOTE 001FENV90/06/07
Sin Rival Anejo 92 PTS January 2011 NO NUM
Tapatio Anejo 38% Alc. Vol. 81 PTS August 2012 1-6121 05/11/07
Tres Generaciones Anejo Re-rating in progress N/A N/A
Trianon Anejo In Progress August 2014 014ANE40
Z Pepe Zevada Tequila Anejo 77 PTS February 2013 APZ010
1800 Tequila Anejo 66 PTS February 2013 09051
3 Amigos Anejo In Progress August 2014 N/A
EXTRA ANEJO
( AGED, MINIMUM OF 3 YEARS)
TEQUILA NAME: RATING POINTS: MONTH/YEAR RATED: BOTTLE No:
Cazadores Extra Anejo 81 PTS June 2012 No. 001352
Cabo Uno Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Cocula Extra Anejo 90 PTS April 2011 NO NUM
Corrido Tequila Extra Anejo 85 PTS December 2012 202/258 Firma: 3-40 RCM Lote No. 17082008-01
DeLeon Extra Anejo Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Don Fulano Imperial Extra Anejo 88 PTS April 2012 LOTE 69DFI9 2801
Don Julio Real 90 PTS January 2011 NO NUM
Don Pilar Extra Anejo (XA) 93 PTS October 2012 2012 / 0449
Don Weber Extra Anejo In Progress August 2014 N/A
El Gran Jubileo Extra Anejo 88 PTS June 2011 NO NUM
El Llano Extra Anejo 91 PTS June 2012 No Num
Gran Centenario Gran Reserva Extra Anejo Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Gran Centenario Leyenda Extra Anejo Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Gran Centenario Reserva del Tequilero Extra Anejo Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Grand Mayan Extra Anejo 95 PTS March 2011 L-22111009
Herradura Seleccion Suprema 91 PTS March 2014 LOTE 12320C1992
Hijo Predilecto Extra Anejo 98 PTS March 2013 0076
Jose Cuervo 250 Aniversario Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Jose Cuervo Reserva De La Familia Anejo 93 PTS April 2011 00316 04-VI-11
Los Azulejos Masterpiece 78 PTS June 2011 No.CANEN 007
Maya Extra Anejo 91 PTS August 2011 UAM226
Ocho Extra Anejo No yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Partida Elegante Not yet rated Not yet rated N/A
Patron Burdeos N/A N/A N/A
Sin Rival Extra Anejo 90 PTS April 2011 4 160410


[tequila_specific_rss_menu]